change puncher API so we can notify the peer after sending out the SYN packets

puncher.nim

@@ -9,12 +9,12 @@ from nativesockets import
 from sequtils import any
 
 type
-  Attempt = object
+  Attempt* = object
     ## A hole punching attempt.
-    srcPort: Port
+    srcPort*: Port
-    dstIp: IpAddress
+    dstIp*: IpAddress
-    dstPorts: seq[Port]
+    dstPorts*: seq[Port]
-    future: Future[Port]
+    future*: Future[Port]
 
   Puncher* = ref object
     sock: AsyncSocket
@@ -39,18 +39,18 @@ proc initPuncher*(sock: AsyncSocket): Puncher =
   Puncher(sock: sock)
 
 proc punch(puncher: Puncher, peerIp: IpAddress, peerPort: Port,
-           peerProbedPorts: seq[Port], lowTTL: bool, msg: string): Future[Port]
+           peerProbedPorts: seq[Port], lowTTL: bool, msg: string):
-          {.async.} =
+          Future[Attempt] {.async.} =
   let punchFuture = newFuture[Port]("punch")
   let predictedDstPorts = predictPortRange(peerPort, peerProbedPorts)
   let (_, myPort) = puncher.sock.getLocalAddr()
-  let attempt = Attempt(srcPort: myPort, dstIp: peerIp,
+  result = Attempt(srcPort: myPort, dstIp: peerIp, dstPorts: predictedDstPorts,
-                        dstPorts: predictedDstPorts, future: punchFuture)
+                   future: punchFuture)
-  if puncher.attempts.contains(attempt):
+  if puncher.attempts.contains(result):
     raise newException(PunchHoleError,
                        "hole punching for given parameters already active")
-  puncher.attempts.add(attempt)
+  puncher.attempts.add(result)
-  echo &"sending msg {msg} to {peerIp}, predicted ports: {attempt.dstPorts}"
+  echo &"sending msg {msg} to {peerIp}, predicted ports: {result.dstPorts}"
   var peerAddr: Sockaddr_storage
   var peerSockLen: SockLen
   try:
@@ -58,29 +58,31 @@ proc punch(puncher: Puncher, peerIp: IpAddress, peerPort: Port,
     if lowTTL:
       defaultTTL = puncher.sock.getFd.getSockOptInt(IPPROTO_IP, IP_TTL)
       puncher.sock.getFd.setSockOptInt(IPPROTO_IP, IP_TTL, 2)
-    for dstPort in attempt.dstPorts:
+    for dstPort in result.dstPorts:
-      toSockAddr(attempt.dstIp, dstPort, peerAddr, peerSockLen)
+      toSockAddr(result.dstIp, dstPort, peerAddr, peerSockLen)
       # TODO: replace asyncdispatch.sendTo with asyncnet.sendTo (Nim 1.4 required)
       await sendTo(puncher.sock.getFd().AsyncFD, msg.cstring, msg.len,
                    cast[ptr SockAddr](addr peerAddr), peerSockLen)
     if lowTTL:
       puncher.sock.getFd.setSockOptInt(IPPROTO_IP, IP_TTL, defaultTTL)
-    await punchFuture or sleepAsync(Timeout)
-    if punchFuture.finished():
-      result = punchFuture.read()
-    else:
-      raise newException(PunchHoleError, "timeout")
   except OSError as e:
     raise newException(PunchHoleError, e.msg)
 
 proc initiate*(puncher: Puncher, peerIp: IpAddress, peerPort: Port,
-               peerProbedPorts: seq[Port]): Future[Port] =
+               peerProbedPorts: seq[Port]): Future[Attempt] =
   punch(puncher, peerIp, peerPort, peerProbedPorts, true, "SYN")
   
 proc respond*(puncher: Puncher, peerIp: IpAddress, peerPort: Port,
-              peerProbedPorts: seq[Port]): Future[Port] =
+              peerProbedPorts: seq[Port]): Future[Attempt] =
   punch(puncher, peerIp, peerPort, peerProbedPorts, false, "ACK")
 
+proc finalize*(attempt: Attempt): Future[Port] {.async.} =
+  await attempt.future or sleepAsync(Timeout)
+  if attempt.future.finished:
+    result = attempt.future.read()
+  else:
+    raise newException(PunchHoleError, "timeout")
+
 proc handleMsg*(puncher: Puncher, msg: string, peerIp: IpAddress,
                 peerPort: Port) =
   ## Handles an incoming UDP message which may complete the Futures returned by

quicp2p.nim

@@ -336,8 +336,9 @@ proc receive(ctx: QuicP2PContext, peerId: string) {.async.} =
 
 proc handleNotification(ctx: QuicP2PContext, notification: NotifyPeer)
                        {.async.} =
-  let _ = await ctx.puncher.respond(notification.srcIp, notification.srcPort,
+  let attempt = await ctx.puncher.respond(notification.srcIp, notification.srcPort,
                                           notification.probedsrcPorts)
+  discard await attempt.finalize()
 
 proc runApp(ctx: QuicP2PContext, srcPort: Port, peerId: string) {.async.} =
   let serverConn = await initServerConnection(rendezvousServers[0].hostname,
@@ -370,9 +371,10 @@ proc runApp(ctx: QuicP2PContext, srcPort: Port, peerId: string) {.async.} =
     let myProbedPorts = serverConn.probedSrcPorts.join(",")
     let peerProbedPorts = peerInfo.probedPorts.join(",")
     let req = &"{ctx.getPeerId()}|{peerId}|{serverConn.probedIp}|{srcPort}|{myProbedPorts}|{peerInfo.ip}|{peerInfo.localPort}|{peerProbedPorts}"
-    discard await serverConn.sendRequest("notify-peer", req)
+    let attempt = await ctx.puncher.initiate(peerInfo.ip, peerInfo.localPort,
-    let peerPort = await ctx.puncher.initiate(peerInfo.ip, peerInfo.localPort,
                                              peerInfo.probedPorts)
+    discard await serverConn.sendRequest("notify-peer", req)
+    let peerPort = await attempt.finalize()
     initiateQuicConnection(ctx, peerId, peerInfo.ip, peerPort)
 
 proc main() =